I only bought it about a month ago and it's been in the way back of the fridge. It's that new wide mouth plastic jar-I usually just get the squeeze bottles. I'm making potatoe salad and when I opened it, it smells fine, but it's a little watery and around the top there was a little bit that looks kinda yellow-ya know, likeif any of you have worked in fast food and that container of mayo. thats gets used all day starts to look yellow. Am I just being paranoid?